I should have posted last night, because I was *so* piqued, but I was way too exhausted from a day of hopeless yarn battle.
You see, I bought a skein of Tofutsies a few days ago, because socks are the most practical project to take to Burning Man and I’ve been excited to try out this yarn. Not only that, but in my extreme financial difficulties, it’s the *only* skein of yarn I’m letting myself buy before I move and get a job. I love the feel of it–wool-sensitive folks need sock yarn too, and the cotton and soysilk in these seems like just the ticket! I haven’t been that excited about a yarn purchase since my first skein of Malabrigo.
I’ve never seen pooling quite like this. I didn’t manage to take any pictures, because knitting and then ripping 3-4 inches of sock all day made me kinda insane. However, I found a pic from someone who had similar problems with the same color:

I actually spent all day trying to make mine look like this–the magenta and black were pooling on one side, and the lavendar and pink on the other, going straight down. I spent all day trying to make them swirl like the knitter above, and failed for the most part. My sock continued to look like a 6 year old girl’s on one side and a goth’s on the other side.
Yesterday in brief:
I start with the intention of making knitty’s Hedera. 4 inches of that on size 1 needles, and gee, I have a problem. No matter, the pattern’s roomy and the yarn is quite fine, I’ll switch it down to size 0′s. Hmm, moving slightly to the left, but still pretty much the same. I adjust the entire pattern down to 54 stitches and put it back on size 1′s. No go. Zeros? No. Ok, ok, maybe this particular lace isn’t happening. Let’s just put plain old women’s medium 56 stitches on size 1 needles and work the leg in a plain old boring rib. No. Size 0 needles? No. (By now you can see that my choices are more about desperation and frustration than logic, which would have made me put these aside halfway through the day.) Ok, I’m desperate. The ball says size 2 needles, and while I’d normally consider that too open for a sock, perhaps the dyers had some plan that will only be revealed to me on size 2 needles. I try basic ribbing on 52 and 48 stitches. Nope, same plan. I then cast on an unprecedented 64 stitches on size 1′s, planning to cable and rib the hell out of them. To be fair, the last one most resembles the pic above, but it still just didn’t *work* and I didn’t really want cabled socks anyway.
By my (not scientific) calculation, I knit somewhere between 17 and 25 inches of sock yesterday. ::Pokes own eye out with size 2 knitting needles::
I wrote a letter to SWTC–which I’ve never done before, and I don’t intend to get in the habit of being one of those annoying people who blames the yarn for all her misfortunes. I used to absolutely hate it when people came into the yarn store and complained about pooling, saying things like, “This yarn isn’t well-made!” Pooling happens. No dyer can anticipate each and every gauge, width, and stitch that you might want to make the yarn into.
But it’s a sock yarn. And I wanted to make a women’s medium sock. It didn’t have to resemble the one on the band or the one on the website exactly(example below), and pools of colors or swirls would have been ok. I sometimes even like pools. They’re like the Rorschach test of the knitting world. I wouldn’t have minded changing needles or the number of stitches a few times to get something that looked good. I’m very forgiving. But this was… new. Is it so wrong to expect that a manufacturer would take the time to at least make sure that a sock yarn would work for a sock? It’s not like I can expect my yarn to come with a warranty (too many variables)–but in my opinion, this skein of yarn is “broken.” If my microwave comes broken, I get a new one. If my yarn comes broken (and this is the first time I’ve ever considered that to be the case), nothing happens unless I bring it back to the very small business I purchased it from and ask them to eat the cost, which I refuse to do. That sucks.

Anyways, we’ll see how they respond to the letter. In the past, I’ve really loved their products, and they were great to deal with as vendors when I was working at TGF. Whatever this post might sound like, I still love SWTC. It just might be a while before I trust their sock yarn.
Late late last night, I cast on “Hedera” again, this time in and old ball of Cherry Tree Hill’s Supersock. This yarn was too fluffy for the pattern and resulted in an enormous cuff. Perhaps I’m just not meant to have those!